RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2020 · PAPER 1+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question — Electric field of continuous charge distributions

A uniform electric field, E→=−4003y^NC−1\overrightarrow{E} = −400\sqrt{3}\hat{y} NC^{−1} is applied in a region. A charged particle of mass m carrying positive charge q is projected in this region with an initial speed of 210×106ms−12\sqrt{10} \times 106 ms^{−1}. This particle is aimed to hit a target T, which is 5 m away from its entry point into the field as shown schematically in the figure. Take qm=1010Ckg−1\frac{q}{m} = 10^{10} Ckg^{−1}. Then

Figure for JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question on Electric field of continuous charge distributions
SOLUTION

The electric field is uniform and points in the negative yy-direction: E→=−4003 y^  N C−1\overrightarrow{E}= -400\sqrt3\,\hat y\;{\rm N\,C^{-1}}.
For a positive charge, the electric force is F→=qE→\overrightarrow{F}=q\overrightarrow{E}, giving an acceleration

a→=qmE→=−qm 4003 y^.\overrightarrow a=\frac{q}{m}\overrightarrow{E}= -\frac{q}{m}\,400\sqrt3\,\hat y.

With qm=1010  C kg−1,\dfrac{q}{m}=10^{10}\;{\rm C\,kg^{-1}}, the magnitude of the (downward) acceleration is
∣a∣=4003×1010  m s−2≈6.928×1012  m s−2.|a|=400\sqrt3\times10^{10}\;{\rm m\,s^{-2}}\approx6.928\times10^{12}\;{\rm m\,s^{-2}}.

The particle enters the field with speed
v0=210×106  m s−1=6.324×106  m s−1.v_0 = 2\sqrt{10}\times10^6\;{\rm m\,s^{-1}} =6.324\times10^{6}\;{\rm m\,s^{-1}}.

Let the projection angle with the horizontal be θ\theta. Components of the initial velocity are v0x=v0cos⁡θ,v0y=v0sin⁡θ.v_{0x}=v_0\cos\theta,\qquad v_{0y}=v_0\sin\theta.

The target T lies 5 m horizontally from the entry point and is on the same vertical level. If tt is the time taken to hit T, the kinematic equations are

Horizontal motion: x(t)=v0xt=5  ⇒  t=5v0cos⁡θ  −(1)x(t)=v_{0x}t=5\;\Rightarrow\;t=\dfrac{5}{v_0\cos\theta}\;-(1)

Vertical motion: y(t)=v0yt+12at2=0  −(2)y(t)=v_{0y}t+\tfrac12 a t^2=0\;-(2) (subscript 0 denotes initial quantities).

Substituting tt from (1)(1) into (2)(2):

v0sin⁡θ  5v0cos⁡θ+12a ⁣(5v0cos⁡θ) ⁣2=0.v_0\sin\theta\;\frac{5}{v_0\cos\theta} +\frac12 a\!\left(\frac{5}{v_0\cos\theta}\right)^{\!2}=0.

After cancelling v0v_0 and simplifying,

5tan⁡θ+25a2v02cos⁡2θ=0    ⟹    tan⁡θ=−5a2v02cos⁡2θ.5\tan\theta+\frac{25a}{2v_0^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}=0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \tan\theta=-\frac{5a}{2v_0^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}.

Because aa is negative (downward), write a=−∣a∣a=-|a|. Then

tan⁡θ=5∣a∣2v02cos⁡2θ.\tan\theta=\frac{5|a|}{2v_0^{2}\cos^{2}\theta}.

Multiply by cos⁡2θ\cos^{2}\theta:

sin⁡θcos⁡θ=5∣a∣2v02.\sin\theta\cos\theta=\frac{5|a|}{2v_0^{2}}.

Using sin⁡θcos⁡θ=12sin⁡2θ\sin\theta\cos\theta=\tfrac12\sin2\theta gives

12sin⁡2θ=5∣a∣2v02⟹sin⁡2θ=5∣a∣v02.\tfrac12\sin2\theta=\frac{5|a|}{2v_0^{2}} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \sin2\theta=\frac{5|a|}{v_0^{2}}.

Compute the right-hand side:

5∣a∣v02=5(6.928×1012)(6.324×106)2=3.464×10134.000×1013≈0.866=32.\frac{5|a|}{v_0^{2}} =\frac{5(6.928\times10^{12})}{(6.324\times10^{6})^{2}} =\frac{3.464\times10^{13}}{4.000\times10^{13}} \approx0.866=\frac{\sqrt3}{2}.

Hence sin⁡2θ=32  ,\sin2\theta= \frac{\sqrt3}{2}\;, so

2θ=60∘    or    120∘⟹θ=30∘    or    60∘.2\theta = 60^{\circ}\;\;{\rm or}\;\;120^{\circ} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \theta = 30^{\circ}\;\;{\rm or}\;\;60^{\circ}.

Thus the particle can hit T when projected at either 30∘30^{\circ} or 60∘60^{\circ}.

Next, compute the time of flight for each angle using (1)(1).

Case 1: θ=30∘\theta = 30^{\circ}.

cos⁡30∘=0.866,\cos30^{\circ}=0.866, so t1=56.324×106×0.866=9.14×10−7  s=0.9136  μs.t_1=\frac{5}{6.324\times10^{6}\times0.866} =9.14\times10^{-7}\;{\rm s} =0.9136\;\mu{\rm s}.

Numerically, 56  μs=0.8333  μs=0.9129  μs,\sqrt{\frac{5}{6}}\;\mu{\rm s} =\sqrt{0.8333}\;\mu{\rm s} =0.9129\;\mu{\rm s}, which matches t1t_1.

Case 2: θ=60∘\theta = 60^{\circ}.

cos⁡60∘=0.5,\cos60^{\circ}=0.5, so t2=56.324×106×0.5=1.582×10−6  s=1.582  μs.t_2=\frac{5}{6.324\times10^{6}\times0.5} =1.582\times10^{-6}\;{\rm s} =1.582\;\mu{\rm s}.

Numerically, 52  μs=2.5  μs=1.582  μs,\sqrt{\frac{5}{2}}\;\mu{\rm s} =\sqrt{2.5}\;\mu{\rm s} =1.582\;\mu{\rm s}, which matches t2t_2.

Therefore two different times of flight are possible: t=56  μsort=52  μs.t=\sqrt{\frac{5}{6}}\;\mu{\rm s}\quad\text{or}\quad t=\sqrt{\frac{5}{2}}\;\mu{\rm s}.

Checking the given statements:

Option A: angle 45∘45^{\circ} ⇒\Rightarrow not satisfied. (False)

Option B: angles 30∘30^{\circ} or 60∘60^{\circ} ⇒\Rightarrow satisfied. (True)

Option C: time could be 5/6 μs\sqrt{5/6}\ \mu{\rm s} as well as 5/2 μs\sqrt{5/2}\ \mu{\rm s} ⇒\Rightarrow satisfied. (True)

Option D: time is 5/3 μs\sqrt{5/3}\ \mu{\rm s} only ⇒\Rightarrow not satisfied. (False)

Hence the correct options are:
Option B (projection angles) and Option C (possible times).

Tagged Electric field of continuous charge distributions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric field of continuous charge distributions
TypeMultiple correct