RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2014 · PAPER 2+3 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2014 Physics question — Electric field of continuous charge distributions

Four charges Q1,Q2,Q3Q_1, Q_2, Q_3 and Q4Q_4 of same magnitude are fixed along the x axis at x = −2a, −a, +a and +2a, respectively. A positive charge q is placed on the positive y axis at a distance b > 0. Four options of the signs of these charges are given in List I. The direction of the forces on the charge q is given in List II. Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the code given below the lists.

Figure for JEE Advanced 2014 Physics question on Electric field of continuous charge distributions
SOLUTION

Key idea: Pair the charges symmetrically (±a\pm a and ±2a\pm 2a) and check which force components cancel.

  • P (all positive): the x-components cancel in pairs and the y-components add, giving a push away from the axis, +y+y. P-3
  • Q (Q1,Q2Q_1,Q_2 positive; Q3,Q4Q_3,Q_4 negative): the positives on the left push qq to +x+x and the negatives on the right pull it to +x+x. The y-components cancel (++ repels, −- attracts by equal amounts). Result: +x+x. Q-1
  • R (Q1,Q4Q_1,Q_4 positive; Q2,Q3Q_2,Q_3 negative): the x-components cancel by symmetry. The inner negatives (at ±a\pm a, closer) attract qq towards the axis more strongly than the outer positives repel it, because b(a2+b2)3/2>b(4a2+b2)3/2\dfrac{b}{(a^2+b^2)^{3/2}} > \dfrac{b}{(4a^2+b^2)^{3/2}}. Result: −y-y. R-4
  • S (Q1,Q3Q_1,Q_3 positive; Q2,Q4Q_2,Q_4 negative): the y-components cancel in pairs. The inner pair (−- at −a-a, ++ at +a+a) drives qq towards −x-x, and the outer pair gives a weaker +x+x. Result: −x-x. S-2

So P-3, Q-1, R-4, S-2.

Answer: (A)

Tagged Electric field of continuous charge distributions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric field of continuous charge distributions
TypeMultiple choice