RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2013 · PAPER 1+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2013 Physics question — Electric flux and Gauss's law

Two non-conducting solid spheres of radii R and 2R, having uniform volume charge densities ρ1\rho_1 and ρ2\rho_2 respectively, touch each other. The net electric field at a distance 2R from the centre of the smaller sphere, along the line joining the centres of the spheres, is zero. The ratio ρ1ρ2\frac{\rho_1}{\rho_2} can be

SOLUTION

Key idea: The centres are 3R3R apart. The point at 2R2R from the small sphere's centre can lie either inside the big sphere (between the centres) or outside both (on the far side).

Field of a uniform sphere: E=ρr3ε0E = \dfrac{\rho r}{3\varepsilon_0} inside, and E=ρa33ε0r2E = \dfrac{\rho a^3}{3\varepsilon_0 r^2} outside (sphere of radius aa).

Case 1: point between the centres (distance RR from the big centre, inside it):

  • Small sphere: E1=ρ1R33ε0(2R)2=ρ1R12ε0E_1 = \dfrac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\varepsilon_0 (2R)^2} = \dfrac{\rho_1 R}{12\varepsilon_0}, directed away from the small sphere.
  • Big sphere: E2=ρ2R3ε0E_2 = \dfrac{\rho_2 R}{3\varepsilon_0}, directed away from the big centre, i.e. opposite to E1E_1.
  • Zero net field needs like signs and ρ112=ρ23⇒ρ1ρ2=4\dfrac{\rho_1}{12} = \dfrac{\rho_2}{3} \Rightarrow \dfrac{\rho_1}{\rho_2} = 4.

Case 2: point on the far side of the small sphere (distance 5R5R from the big centre):

  • E1=ρ1R12ε0E_1 = \dfrac{\rho_1 R}{12\varepsilon_0} and E2=ρ2(2R)33ε0(5R)2=8ρ2R75ε0E_2 = \dfrac{\rho_2 (2R)^3}{3\varepsilon_0 (5R)^2} = \dfrac{8\rho_2 R}{75\varepsilon_0}. For like signs both point the same way, so the charges must have opposite signs: ρ112=−8ρ275⇒ρ1ρ2=−3225\frac{\rho_1}{12} = -\frac{8\rho_2}{75} \Rightarrow \frac{\rho_1}{\rho_2} = -\frac{32}{25}

Answer: (B), (D)

Tagged Electric flux and Gauss's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric flux and Gauss's law
TypeMultiple correct