RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2020 · PAPER 1+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question — Electric current, current density and drift velocity

Shown in the figure is a semicircular metallic strip that has thickness t and resistivity ρ\rho. Its inner radius is R1R_{1} and outer radius is R2R_{2}. If a voltage V0V_{0} is applied between its two ends, a current I flows in it. In addition, it is observed that a transverse voltage △V\triangle V develops between its inner and outer surfaces due to purely kinetic effects of moving electrons (ignore any role of the magnetic field due to the current). Then (figure is schematic and not drawn to scale)

Figure for JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question on Electric current, current density and drift velocity
SOLUTION

Consider a thin semicircular metallic strip that lies in the plane of the page. Its thickness (perpendicular to the page) is tt, the inner radius is R1R_1 and the outer radius is R2R_2. A potential difference V0V_0 is applied between the two radial ends, so that current flows along the semicircular path (tangential direction).

1. Equivalent resistance of the strip

Take a differential concentric element of width drdr at radius rr.
Length of this element (semicircle)  =  πr\pi r.
Cross-sectional area offered to the tangential current  =  t drt\,dr.
Hence its differential resistance is

dR  =  ρ lengtharea  =  ρ πrt drdR \;=\; \rho\,\dfrac{\text{length}}{\text{area}} \;=\; \rho\,\dfrac{\pi r}{t\,dr}

All such elements are connected in parallel between the same pair of electrodes, so we add their conductances:

dG  =  1dR  =  t drρ πrdG \;=\; \dfrac{1}{dR} \;=\; \dfrac{t\,dr}{\rho\,\pi r} G  =  ∫R1R2dG  =  tρ π∫R1R2drr  =  tρ πln⁡ ⁣(R2R1)G \;=\; \displaystyle\int_{R_1}^{R_2} dG \;=\; \dfrac{t}{\rho\,\pi}\int_{R_1}^{R_2}\dfrac{dr}{r} \;=\; \dfrac{t}{\rho\,\pi}\ln\!\left(\dfrac{R_2}{R_1}\right)

Therefore the equivalent resistance is

R  =  1G  =  ρ πt  ln⁡(R2/R1)R \;=\; \dfrac{1}{G} \;=\; \dfrac{\rho\,\pi}{t\;\ln(R_2/R_1)}

2. Current between the two ends

I  =  V0R  =  V0 tρ π ln⁡ ⁣(R2R1)I \;=\; \dfrac{V_0}{R} \;=\; \dfrac{V_0\,t}{\rho\,\pi}\,\ln\!\left(\dfrac{R_2}{R_1}\right)

This is exactly the expression given in Option A, so Option A is correct.

3. Drift speed and the required radial (centripetal) force

For the shell at radius rr the current through that shell is

dI  =  V0 dG  =  V0 t drρ πrdI \;=\; V_0\,dG \;=\; V_0\,\dfrac{t\,dr}{\rho\,\pi r}

Current density in that shell:

J(r)  =  dIt dr  =  V0ρ πrJ(r) \;=\; \dfrac{dI}{t\,dr} \;=\; \dfrac{V_0}{\rho\,\pi r}

If the free-electron number density is nn and electron charge is −e-e, the drift velocity is

vd(r)  =  J(r)n e  =  V0ρ π n e rv_d(r) \;=\; \dfrac{J(r)}{n\,e} \;=\; \dfrac{V_0}{\rho\,\pi\,n\,e\,r}

Every electron must execute circular motion, so it needs a centripetal acceleration ac=vd2ra_c = \dfrac{v_d^2}{r}, directed radially inwards. The only force available (magnetic field is to be ignored) is the electric force −eEr-eE_r caused by a radial electric field ErE_r inside the strip:

me vd2r  =  −e Erm_e\,\dfrac{v_d^2}{r} \;=\; -e\,E_r (The left side is inward, hence negative in the outward radial direction.) Therefore

Er(r)  =  mee vd2r  =  mee V02ρ2 π2 n2 e2 1r3(directed outward)E_r(r) \;=\; \dfrac{m_e}{e}\,\dfrac{v_d^2}{r} \;=\; \dfrac{m_e}{e}\, \dfrac{V_0^2}{\rho^2\,\pi^2\,n^2\,e^2}\, \dfrac{1}{r^3} \quad (\text{directed outward})

4. Radial potential difference

Potential difference between the outer and inner surfaces is

ΔV  =  Vouter−Vinner  =  − ⁣∫R1R2Er(r) dr\Delta V \;=\; V_{\text{outer}} - V_{\text{inner}} \;=\; -\!\int_{R_1}^{R_2} E_r(r)\,dr ΔV  =  −mee V02ρ2 π2 n2 e2∫R1R2drr3\Delta V \;=\; -\dfrac{m_e}{e}\, \dfrac{V_0^2}{\rho^2\,\pi^2\,n^2\,e^2} \int_{R_1}^{R_2}\dfrac{dr}{r^3} ΔV  =  −mee V022 ρ2 π2 n2 e2(1R22−1R12)\Delta V \;=\; -\dfrac{m_e}{e}\, \dfrac{V_0^2}{2\,\rho^2\,\pi^2\,n^2\,e^2} \left(\dfrac{1}{R_2^{2}} - \dfrac{1}{R_1^{2}}\right)

(a) The negative sign shows that Vouter<VinnerV_{\text{outer}} \lt V_{\text{inner}}, i.e. the outer surface is at a lower potential.
    This validates Option C and rules out Option B.

(b) All parameters other than V0V_0 (or equivalently II) are constant, so

∣ΔV∣  ∝  V0 2  ∝  I 2|\Delta V| \;\propto\; V_0^{\,2} \;\propto\; I^{\,2}

Hence Option D is also correct.

5. Final set of correct choices

Option A (current expression), Option C (outer surface at lower potential), and Option D (transverse voltage ∝I2\propto I^{2}) are correct.

Tagged Electric current, current density and drift velocity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric current, current density and drift velocity
TypeMultiple correct