Key idea: If no current flows in R2, its two ends (the middle-left and middle-right nodes) are at the same potential. The rest of the circuit is then one series loop.
In the figure, the left vertical wire joins the middle-left node to the bottom-left node, so R2's left end is at the same potential as the bottom wire.
- With IR2=0, the potential difference across R1 equals the emf V1, so I=R1V1.
- The same current flows on through V2 and R3 back to the bottom-left node. For the middle-right node to be at the same potential as the middle-left node, the drop across R3 must balance V2: I=R3V2.
- Condition: R1V1=R3V2, i.e. V2V1=R3R1. Note that R2 does not appear.
- Check the options:
- (A) 1=1 ✓
- (B) V1=V2 and R1=R3 ✓
- (C) V1/V2=2 but R1/R3=1/2 ✗
- (D) V1/V2=1/2 and R1/R3=1/2 ✓
Answer: (A), (B), (D)