RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 1+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Capacitors with dielectrics

A medium having dielectric constant K>1K > 1 fills the space between the plates of a parallel plate capacitor. The plates have large area, and the distance between them is dd. The capacitor is connected to a battery of voltage VV, as shown in Figure (a). Now, both the plates are moved by a distance of d2\frac{d}{2} from their original positions, as shown in Figure (b).

Figure for JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question on Capacitors with dielectrics

In the process of going from the configuration depicted in Figure (a) to that in Figure (b), which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

SOLUTION

Let the area of each plate be AA (very large) and let the battery keep the potential difference between the plates fixed at VV throughout the entire process.

Initial configuration - Figure (a)
• Separation between plates = dd.
• The whole region between the plates is filled with a dielectric of constant KK.
Hence

Capacitance: Ci=ε0KAdC_i = \dfrac{\varepsilon_0 K A}{d} −(1)-(1)

Electric field inside the dielectric:
Since the potential difference is VV and the field is uniform, Ei=VdE_i = \dfrac{V}{d} −(2)-(2)

Final configuration - Figure (b)
• Each plate is pulled away from its original position by d2\dfrac{d}{2}, so the new plate separation is d+d2+d2=2dd + \dfrac{d}{2} + \dfrac{d}{2} = 2d.
• The dielectric slab remains where it was; its thickness is still dd and it now occupies the middle part of the gap.
Thus the space between the plates consists of three layers placed one after another (in series):
  1. Vacuum of thickness d2\dfrac{d}{2},
  2. Dielectric of thickness dd and constant KK,
  3. Vacuum of thickness d2\dfrac{d}{2}.

Equivalent capacitance in the final set-up
For layers in series, the capacitance per unit area is found from 1Cf/A=d1ε0+d2ε0K+d3ε0\dfrac{1}{C_f/A} = \dfrac{d_1}{\varepsilon_0} + \dfrac{d_2}{\varepsilon_0 K} + \dfrac{d_3}{\varepsilon_0}

Here d1=d3=d2,d2=dd_1 = d_3 = \dfrac{d}{2},\qquad d_2 = d.
Therefore

1Cf/A=d/2ε0+dε0K+d/2ε0=dε0+dε0K=dε0(1+1K)=dε0 K+1K\dfrac{1}{C_f/A} = \dfrac{d/2}{\varepsilon_0} + \dfrac{d}{\varepsilon_0 K} + \dfrac{d/2}{\varepsilon_0} = \dfrac{d}{\varepsilon_0} + \dfrac{d}{\varepsilon_0 K} = \dfrac{d}{\varepsilon_0}\Bigl(1 + \dfrac{1}{K}\Bigr) = \dfrac{d}{\varepsilon_0}\,\dfrac{K+1}{K}

Hence

Cf=ε0AKd (K+1)C_f = \dfrac{\varepsilon_0 A K}{d\,(K+1)} −(3)-(3)

Comparison of capacitances
Using (1)(1) and (3)(3),

CfCi=ε0AKd (K+1)/ε0KAd=1K+1\dfrac{C_f}{C_i} = \dfrac{\varepsilon_0 A K}{d\,(K+1)} \bigg/ \dfrac{\varepsilon_0 K A}{d} = \dfrac{1}{K+1}

Thus the capacitance decreases by the factor 1K+1\dfrac{1}{K+1}. Statement B is correct.

Electric fields in the final configuration
Let E0E_0 be the field in either vacuum gap and EdE_d the field in the dielectric. Because there is no free charge inside, the displacement field is continuous: ε0E0=ε0KEd  ⟹  E0=KEd\varepsilon_0 E_0 = \varepsilon_0 K E_d \;\Longrightarrow\; E_0 = K E_d −(4)-(4)

The total potential difference is still VV (battery connected):

V=E0(d2+d2)+Ed(d)=dE0+dEd=d(E0+Ed)V = E_0\Bigl(\dfrac{d}{2} + \dfrac{d}{2}\Bigr) + E_d (d) = dE_0 + dE_d = d\bigl(E_0 + E_d\bigr)

Using (4)(4), E0+Ed=KEd+Ed=Ed(K+1)E_0 + E_d = K E_d + E_d = E_d (K+1). Hence

Ed=Vd (K+1),E0=VKd (K+1)E_d = \dfrac{V}{d\,(K+1)},\qquad E_0 = \dfrac{VK}{d\,(K+1)}

Comparing EdE_d with the initial field Ei=VdE_i = \dfrac{V}{d} (from (2)(2)), we get EdEi=1K+1\dfrac{E_d}{E_i} = \dfrac{1}{K+1}, not 12K\dfrac{1}{2K}. Therefore Statement A is false.

Voltage between the plates
It remains fixed at VV, so it is certainly not multiplied by (K+1)(K+1). Statement C is false.

Work done
The energy stored initially: Ui=12CiV2U_i = \dfrac{1}{2} C_i V^2.
The energy stored finally: Uf=12CfV2U_f = \dfrac{1}{2} C_f V^2.
Because Cf≠CiC_f \neq C_i and depends on KK, the work (equal to Ui−UfU_i - U_f, any difference being supplied by the battery) does depend on the dielectric. Statement D is false.

Only Statement B is correct.
Option B which is: The capacitance is decreased by a factor of 1K+1\dfrac{1}{K+1}.

Tagged Capacitors with dielectrics. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCapacitors with dielectrics
TypeMultiple correct