The binding energy of nucleons in a nucleus can be affected by the pairwise Coulomb repulsion. Assume that all nucleons are uniformly distributed inside the nucleus. Let the binding energy of a proton be and the binding energy of a neutron be in the nucleus.
Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?
The extra effect that distinguishes a proton from a neutron inside a nucleus is the electrostatic (Coulomb) repulsion among protons. All other (strong-interaction) pieces of the binding energy are the same for both nucleons.
1. Coulomb energy of a uniformly charged nucleus
For a uniformly charged sphere of radius containing protons, the total Coulomb potential energy is
(the factor counts the number of distinct proton pairs). The nuclear radius follows the empirical relation
so
Hence the Coulomb contribution is proportional to and also to .
2. Difference between proton and neutron binding energies
A neutron carries no charge, so its binding energy is unaffected by the Coulomb term.
For a proton, the repulsive energy reduces its binding.
Therefore
where is a positive constant. Thus the magnitude of the difference is indeed proportional to and to , but the sign is negative (a proton is less tightly bound than a neutron).
3. Checking each statement
Case A: True — the proportionality appears directly from the expression above. Case B: True — the same expression also contains the factor . Case C: is positive False — the calculated sign is negative. Case D: increases if the nucleus emits a positron (β+ decay) In β+ decay a proton converts to a neutron, so decreases by 1. The Coulomb repulsion term becomes smaller, which reduces the penalty on the remaining protons; consequently the binding energy of a proton becomes larger. Hence the statement is true.Therefore the correct options are:
Option A, Option B and Option D.
Tagged Radioactivity: decay law, half-life and decay modes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.