A heavy nucleus N, at rest, undergoes fission , where P and Q are two lighter nuclei. Let , where , and are the masses of P, Q and N, respectively. EP and EQ are the kinetic energies of P and Q, respectively. The speeds of P and Q are and , respectively. If c is the speed of light, which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?
The parent nucleus is initially at rest, so its four-momentum is .
After fission we have two product nuclei and with four-momenta
where are the total (rest + kinetic) energies and the kinetic energies are .
Step 1 : Momentum conservation
Because the initial momentum is zero, the two fragments recoil in opposite directions with equal magnitude:
Step 2 : Energy conservation
The time component of four-momentum gives
Rewrite in terms of kinetic energies:
Collecting the rest-mass terms,
By definition , therefore
Equation is independent of whether the fragments move non-relativistically or relativistically; it follows only from energy-momentum conservation. Hence
Option A is always correct.
Why the other options are not guaranteed
Option B claims . To decide this we need the individual kinetic energies. Using only conservation laws we have two unknowns () but just one equation , so their individual values are not fixed by masses alone. The quoted expression can be obtained only under the extra, non-relativistic assumption , which is not stated in the question. Therefore Option B is not necessarily true.
Option C states . Relativistically , so
in general. Again, the quoted ratio holds only in the non-relativistic limit where . Hence Option C is not generally valid.
Option D proposes . Starting from the exact relation
substituting into energy conservation gives a quadratic equation for that does not simplify to the quoted form. The expression again appears only when the kinetic energies are assumed much smaller than the rest energies (so etc.). Without that approximation Option D is incorrect.
Hence, under the general, relativistically correct treatment of nuclear fission, only
Option A which is:
is universally correct.
Tagged Nuclear fission, fusion and Q-value. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.