RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2021 · PAPER 2+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2021 Physics question — Nuclear fission, fusion and Q-value

A heavy nucleus N, at rest, undergoes fission N→P+QN \rightarrow P + Q, where P and Q are two lighter nuclei. Let δ=MN−MP−MQ\delta = M_N − M_P − M_Q, where MPM_P, MQM_Q and MNM_N are the masses of P, Q and N, respectively. EP and EQ are the kinetic energies of P and Q, respectively. The speeds of P and Q are vPv_P and vQv_Q, respectively. If c is the speed of light, which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

SOLUTION

The parent nucleus NN is initially at rest, so its four-momentum is (MNc, 0)\left(M_Nc,\,0\right).

After fission we have two product nuclei PP and QQ with four-momenta

PP=(EPt/c,  p⃗P),PQ=(EQt/c,  p⃗Q)P_P=\left(E_P^t/c,\;\vec p_P\right),\qquad P_Q=\left(E_Q^t/c,\;\vec p_Q\right)
where EPt=EP+MPc2,  EQt=EQ+MQc2E_P^t=E_P+M_Pc^2,\;E_Q^t=E_Q+M_Qc^2 are the total (rest + kinetic) energies and the kinetic energies are EP,  EQE_P,\;E_Q.

Step 1 : Momentum conservation
Because the initial momentum is zero, the two fragments recoil in opposite directions with equal magnitude:

p⃗P+p⃗Q=0    ⟹    pP=pQ  (≡p).\vec p_P+\vec p_Q=0\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;p_P=p_Q\;(\equiv p).

Step 2 : Energy conservation
The time component of four-momentum gives

EPt+EQt=MNc2.E_P^t+E_Q^t=M_Nc^2.

Rewrite in terms of kinetic energies:

(EP+MPc2)+(EQ+MQc2)=MNc2.\bigl(E_P+M_Pc^2\bigr)+\bigl(E_Q+M_Qc^2\bigr)=M_Nc^2.

Collecting the rest-mass terms,

EP+EQ=(MN−MP−MQ)c2.E_P+E_Q=\bigl(M_N-M_P-M_Q\bigr)c^2.

By definition δ=MN−MP−MQ\delta = M_N-M_P-M_Q, therefore

EP+EQ=c2δ  .−(1)E_P+E_Q=c^2\delta\;.\qquad-(1)

Equation (1)(1) is independent of whether the fragments move non-relativistically or relativistically; it follows only from energy-momentum conservation. Hence

Option A is always correct.

Why the other options are not guaranteed

Option B claims EP=MPMP+MQ c2δE_P=\dfrac{M_P}{M_P+M_Q}\,c^2\delta. To decide this we need the individual kinetic energies. Using only conservation laws we have two unknowns (EP, EQE_P,\,E_Q) but just one equation (1)(1), so their individual values are not fixed by masses alone. The quoted expression can be obtained only under the extra, non-relativistic assumption E≪Mc2E\ll M c^2, which is not stated in the question. Therefore Option B is not necessarily true.

Option C states vP/vQ=MQ/MPv_P/v_Q = M_Q/M_P. Relativistically v=pc2Etv=\dfrac{pc^2}{E^t}, so

vPvQ=EQtEPt≠MQMP\frac{v_P}{v_Q}=\frac{E_Q^t}{E_P^t}\neq\frac{M_Q}{M_P} in general. Again, the quoted ratio holds only in the non-relativistic limit p≪Mcp\ll Mc where Et≈Mc2E^t\approx Mc^2. Hence Option C is not generally valid.

Option D proposes p=c2μδ  ,    μ=MPMQMP+MQp=c\sqrt{2\mu\delta}\;,\;\; \mu=\dfrac{M_PM_Q}{M_P+M_Q}. Starting from the exact relation

EPt=(pc)2+MP2c4,  EQt=(pc)2+MQ2c4,E_P^t=\sqrt{(pc)^2+M_P^2c^4},\;E_Q^t=\sqrt{(pc)^2+M_Q^2c^4},

substituting into energy conservation gives a quadratic equation for pp that does not simplify to the quoted form. The expression p=c2μδp=c\sqrt{2\mu\delta} again appears only when the kinetic energies are assumed much smaller than the rest energies (so EP≈p2/2MPE_P\approx p^2/2M_P etc.). Without that approximation Option D is incorrect.

Hence, under the general, relativistically correct treatment of nuclear fission, only

Option A which is: EP+EQ=c2δE_P+E_Q=c^2\delta

is universally correct.

Tagged Nuclear fission, fusion and Q-value. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicNuclear fission, fusion and Q-value
TypeMultiple correct