RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2024 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2024 Mathematics question — Limits of trigonometric functions

Let SS be the set of all (α,β)∈R×R(\alpha, \beta) \in \mathbb{R} \times \mathbb{R} such that

lim⁡x→∞sin⁡(x2)(log⁡ex)αsin⁡(1x2)xαβ(log⁡e(1+x))β=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{\sin(x^2)(\log_e x)^\alpha \sin\left(\frac{1}{x^2}\right)}{x^{\alpha\beta}(\log_e(1+x))^\beta} = 0

Then which of the following is (are) correct?

SOLUTION

Write the given expression as f(x)=sin⁡(x2)  (log⁡ex)α  sin⁡ ⁣(1x2)xαβ  (log⁡e(1+x))βf(x)=\dfrac{\sin(x^{2})\;(\log_e x)^{\alpha}\;\sin\!\left(\dfrac{1}{x^{2}}\right)}{x^{\alpha\beta}\;(\log_e(1+x))^{\beta}} and study lim⁡x→∞f(x)\displaystyle\lim_{x\to\infty}f(x).

Step 1 : Approximate each elementary factor for large xx
(i) sin⁡(x2)\sin(x^{2}) is always bounded: ∣sin⁡(x2)∣≤1|\sin(x^{2})|\le1.
(ii) For very small argument, sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta\approx\theta, so sin⁡ ⁣(1x2)≈1x2\sin\!\left(\dfrac{1}{x^{2}}\right)\approx\dfrac{1}{x^{2}} when x→∞x\to\infty.
(iii) log⁡e(1+x)∼log⁡ex\log_e(1+x)\sim\log_e x as x→∞x\to\infty.

Step 2 : Construct the asymptotic form of f(x)f(x)
Using (i)-(iii):

f(x)∼(log⁡ex)α  1x2xαβ  (log⁡ex)β=(log⁡ex)α−βx 2+αβ .(-1)f(x)\sim \dfrac{(\log_e x)^{\alpha}\;\dfrac{1}{x^{2}}}{x^{\alpha\beta}\;(\log_e x)^{\beta}} =\dfrac{(\log_e x)^{\alpha-\beta}}{x^{\,2+\alpha\beta}}\,.\tag{-1}

Set L(x)=(log⁡ex)α−βx 2+αβL(x)=\dfrac{(\log_e x)^{\alpha-\beta}}{x^{\,2+\alpha\beta}}. Since ∣sin⁡(x2)∣≤1|\sin(x^{2})|\le 1, the original limit equals lim⁡x→∞L(x)\displaystyle\lim_{x\to\infty}L(x).

Step 3 : Decide when L(x)→0L(x)\to 0
Compare the polynomial factor x2+αβx^{2+\alpha\beta} with the logarithmic factor.

Case 1: 2+αβ>02+\alpha\beta\gt0 Then the denominator grows like a positive power of xx. Because any power of log⁡ex\log_e x grows slower than any positive power of xx, the fraction tends to 00.

Case 2: 2+αβ=02+\alpha\beta=0 Here L(x)∼(log⁡ex)α−βL(x)\sim(\log_e x)^{\alpha-\beta}. • If α−β<0\alpha-\beta\lt0, the logarithmic power is negative, so L(x)→0L(x)\to0.
• If α−β≥0\alpha-\beta\ge0, the limit is ≥1\ge1 and not zero.

Case 3: 2+αβ<02+\alpha\beta\lt0 Now the denominator behaves like xnegative powerx^{\text{negative power}}, which tends to 00, so L(x)→∞L(x)\to\infty and the limit is not zero.

Therefore the limit is 00 exactly when 2+αβ>0or2+αβ=0 and α−β<0 .(-2)\boxed{2+\alpha\beta\gt0}\quad\text{or}\quad\boxed{2+\alpha\beta=0\ \text{and}\ \alpha-\beta\lt0}\,.\tag{-2}

Step 4 : Test each option

Option A : (α,β)=(−1,3)(\alpha,\beta)=(-1,3) αβ=−3,  2+αβ=−1<0  (Case 3)  ⟹  \alpha\beta=-3,\;2+\alpha\beta=-1\lt0\;(\text{Case 3})\implies limit ≠0. Hence not in SS.

Option B : (α,β)=(−1,1)(\alpha,\beta)=(-1,1) αβ=−1,  2+αβ=1>0  (Case 1)  ⟹  \alpha\beta=-1,\;2+\alpha\beta=1\gt0\;(\text{Case 1})\implies limit =0=0. Thus (−1,1)∈S(-1,1)\in S.

Option C : (α,β)=(1,−1)(\alpha,\beta)=(1,-1) αβ=−1,  2+αβ=1>0  (Case 1)  ⟹  \alpha\beta=-1,\;2+\alpha\beta=1\gt0\;(\text{Case 1})\implies limit =0=0. Thus (1,−1)∈S(1,-1)\in S.

Option D : (α,β)=(1,−2)(\alpha,\beta)=(1,-2) αβ=−2,  2+αβ=0 (Case 2)\alpha\beta=-2,\;2+\alpha\beta=0\ (\text{Case 2}) and α−β=1−(−2)=3>0\alpha-\beta=1-(-2)=3\gt0, so the required condition α−β<0\alpha-\beta\lt0 is violated. Hence limit ≠0 and the pair is not in SS.

Conclusion
The correct statements are
Option B which is: (−1,1)∈S(-1,1)\in S,
Option C which is: (1,−1)∈S(1,-1)\in S.

Tagged Limits of trigonometric functions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

ChapterLimits
TopicLimits of trigonometric functions
TypeMultiple correct