Write the given expression as f(x)=xαβ(loge(1+x))βsin(x2)(logex)αsin(x21) and study x→∞limf(x).
Step 1 : Approximate each elementary factor for large x
(i) sin(x2) is always bounded: ∣sin(x2)∣≤1.
(ii) For very small argument, sinθ≈θ, so sin(x21)≈x21 when x→∞.
(iii) loge(1+x)∼logex as x→∞.
Step 2 : Construct the asymptotic form of f(x)
Using (i)-(iii):
f(x)∼xαβ(logex)β(logex)αx21=x2+αβ(logex)α−β.(-1)
Set L(x)=x2+αβ(logex)α−β.
Since ∣sin(x2)∣≤1, the original limit equals x→∞limL(x).
Step 3 : Decide when L(x)→0
Compare the polynomial factor x2+αβ with the logarithmic factor.
Case 1: 2+αβ>0
Then the denominator grows like a positive power of x.
Because any power of logex grows slower than any positive power of x, the fraction tends to 0.
Case 2: 2+αβ=0
Here L(x)∼(logex)α−β.
• If α−β<0, the logarithmic power is negative, so L(x)→0.
• If α−β≥0, the limit is ≥1 and not zero.
Case 3: 2+αβ<0
Now the denominator behaves like xnegative power, which tends to 0, so L(x)→∞ and the limit is not zero.
Therefore the limit is 0 exactly when
2+αβ>0or2+αβ=0 and α−β<0.(-2)
Step 4 : Test each option
Option A : (α,β)=(−1,3)
αβ=−3,2+αβ=−1<0(Case 3)⟹ limit ≠0.
Hence not in S.
Option B : (α,β)=(−1,1)
αβ=−1,2+αβ=1>0(Case 1)⟹ limit =0.
Thus (−1,1)∈S.
Option C : (α,β)=(1,−1)
αβ=−1,2+αβ=1>0(Case 1)⟹ limit =0.
Thus (1,−1)∈S.
Option D : (α,β)=(1,−2)
αβ=−2,2+αβ=0 (Case 2) and
α−β=1−(−2)=3>0, so the required condition α−β<0 is violated.
Hence limit ≠0 and the pair is not in S.
Conclusion
The correct statements are
Option B which is: (−1,1)∈S,
Option C which is: (1,−1)∈S.