RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2023 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2023 Mathematics question — Differentiability at a point

Let f:(0,1)→Rf : (0,1) \to \mathbb{R} be the function defined as f(x)=[4x](x−14)2(x−12)f(x) = [4x]\left(x - \frac{1}{4}\right)^2\left(x - \frac{1}{2}\right), where [x][x] denotes the greatest integer less than or equal to xx. Then which of the following statements is(are) true?

SOLUTION

For x∈(0,1)x \in (0,1) the term [4x][4x] (greatest-integer function) is constant on each open sub-interval of length 14\tfrac14.
Explicitly

[4x]={0,0<x<141,14≤x<122,12≤x<343,34≤x<1[4x]=\begin{cases} 0,& 0\lt x\lt \tfrac14\\ 1,& \tfrac14\le x\lt \tfrac12\\ 2,& \tfrac12\le x\lt \tfrac34\\ 3,& \tfrac34\le x\lt 1 \end{cases}

Hence the given function is

f(x)={0,0<x<14(x−14)2 (x−12),14≤x<122 (x−14)2 (x−12),12≤x<343 (x−14)2 (x−12),34≤x<1f(x)=\begin{cases} 0,& 0\lt x\lt \tfrac14\\[4pt] (x-\tfrac14)^2\,(x-\tfrac12),& \tfrac14\le x\lt \tfrac12\\[4pt] 2\,(x-\tfrac14)^2\,(x-\tfrac12),& \tfrac12\le x\lt \tfrac34\\[4pt] 3\,(x-\tfrac14)^2\,(x-\tfrac12),& \tfrac34\le x\lt 1 \end{cases}

The only points where discontinuity or non-differentiability can occur are the junctions x=14, 12, 34x=\tfrac14,\ \tfrac12,\ \tfrac34 because inside each open interval the formula is a polynomial.

Case 1: x=14x=\tfrac14

Left-hand value: lim⁡x→(14)−f(x)=0\lim_{x\to(\tfrac14)^-}f(x)=0 (since f=0f=0 on the first interval).
Function value: f(14)=1⋅02(−14)=0f(\tfrac14)=1\cdot0^2(-\tfrac14)=0.
Right-hand value: lim⁡x→(14)+(x−14)2(x−12)=0\lim_{x\to(\tfrac14)^+}(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12)=0.
All three coincide, so the function is continuous.

For x≥14x\ge\tfrac14 write g(x)=(x−14)2(x−12)g(x)=(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12). Then g′(x)=2(x−14)(x−12)+(x−14)2g'(x)=2(x-\tfrac14)(x-\tfrac12)+(x-\tfrac14)^2.
Evaluating at x=14x=\tfrac14 gives g′(14)=0g'(\tfrac14)=0, whereas the left derivative (from the constant zero part) is also 00. Thus ff is differentiable at x=14x=\tfrac14.

Case 2: x=12x=\tfrac12

Left-hand value: lim⁡x→(12)−(x−14)2(x−12)=0\lim_{x\to(\tfrac12)^-}(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12)=0.
Right-hand value: lim⁡x→(12)+2(x−14)2(x−12)=0\lim_{x\to(\tfrac12)^+}2(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12)=0.
Function value: f(12)=2⋅(14)2⋅0=0f(\tfrac12)=2\cdot(\tfrac14)^2\cdot0=0.
Therefore ff is continuous at x=12x=\tfrac12.

Left derivative: g′(12)=116g'(\tfrac12)=\tfrac1{16}.
Right derivative: ddx[ 2g(x) ]∣x=12=2g′(12)=18\dfrac{d}{dx}[\,2g(x)\,]\big|_{x=\tfrac12}=2g'(\tfrac12)=\tfrac18.
Because 116≠18\tfrac1{16}\ne\tfrac18, the derivatives differ and ff is not differentiable at x=12x=\tfrac12.

Case 3: x=34x=\tfrac34

Left-hand value: lim⁡x→(34)−2(x−14)2(x−12)=2(12)2(14)=18\lim_{x\to(\tfrac34)^-}2(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12)=2\bigl(\tfrac12\bigr)^2\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\tfrac18.
Right-hand value: lim⁡x→(34)+3(x−14)2(x−12)=3(12)2(14)=316\lim_{x\to(\tfrac34)^+}3(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12)=3\bigl(\tfrac12\bigr)^2\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\tfrac{3}{16}.
Since the limits are unequal, ff is discontinuous at x=34x=\tfrac34.

There are no other points to check, so

• ff is discontinuous only at x=34x=\tfrac34 ⇒\Rightarrow exactly one point of discontinuity in (0,1)(0,1).
• Among the remaining junctions, only x=12x=\tfrac12 is continuous but not differentiable ⇒\Rightarrow exactly one such point.

Hence Options A and B are true.

Concerning Option C: non-differentiability occurs at x=12x=\tfrac12 (corner) and x=34x=\tfrac34 (discontinuity), i.e. at two points, not “more than three” ⇒\Rightarrow Option C is false.

Concerning Option D: the function can be negative only on (14,12)(\tfrac14,\tfrac12) where h(x)=(x−14)2(x−12)h(x)=(x-\tfrac14)^2(x-\tfrac12). Setting h′(x)=0h'(x)=0 yields the critical point x=512x=\tfrac5{12}. At this point h ⁣(512)=(16)2 ⁣(−112)=−1432h\!\left(\tfrac5{12}\right)=\left(\tfrac1{6}\right)^2\!\left(-\tfrac1{12}\right)=-\tfrac1{432}. Since this is less than −1512-\tfrac1{512}, the claimed minimum is incorrect ⇒\Rightarrow Option D is false.

Final result: Option A and Option B are the only correct statements.

Tagged Differentiability at a point. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicDifferentiability at a point
TypeMultiple correct