JEE Advanced 2022 Mathematics question — Position of two circles and common tangents
Let G be a circle of radius R > 0. Let G1, G2, ..., Gn be n circles of equal radius r>0. Suppose each of the n circles G1, G2, ..., Gn touches the circle G externally. Also, for i=1,2,...,n−1, the circle Gi touches Gi+1 externally, and Gn touches G1 externally. Then, which of the following statements is/are TRUE?
SOLUTION
Let the centre of the big circle G be O and its radius be R.
Each small circle Gi has centre Ai and radius r.
Because every Gi touches G externally, the distance OAi is the sum of the radii: OAi=R+r.
Because consecutive circles Gi and Gi+1 touch externally, the distance between their centres is AiAi+1=2r.
The centres A1,A2,…,An are therefore the vertices of a regular n-gon inscribed in the circle with centre O and radius R+r.
Hence the central angle between two consecutive vertices is θ=n2π.
Consider the isosceles triangle OAiAi+1. Applying the cosine rule,
Thus the ratio rR depends only on n through θ=n2π.
Case 1:n=4(θ=2π,cosθ=0)
rR=2−1,so R=(2−1)r.
Option A claims (2−1)r<R, but we have equality; therefore Option A is false.
Case 2:n=5(θ=52π,cosθ≈0.3090)
rR=1−0.30902−1≈0.83121.4142−1≈0.698.
Hence R≈0.698r, i.e. R<r.
Option B states r<R, which is false.
Case 3:n=8(θ=4π,cosθ=22=0.7071)
rR=1−0.70712−1=0.29291.4142−1=0.54121.4142−1≈1.613.
Therefore R≈1.613r>(2−1)r(≈0.414r).
So the inequality (2−1)r<R holds.
Option C is true.
Case 4:n=12(θ=6π,cosθ=23=0.8660)
rR=1−0.86602−1=0.13401.4142−1=0.36601.4142−1≈2.866.
Compute 2(3+1)=1.4142(1.732+1)=1.4142×2.732≈3.866.
Since 3.866r>2.866r=R, we have 2(3+1)r>R.
Option D is true.
Hence the correct statements are:
Option C (If n=8, then (2−1)r<R)
Option D (If n=12, then 2(3+1)r>R).
Tagged Position of two circles and common tangents. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.