RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Mathematics question — Position of two circles and common tangents

Let G be a circle of radius R > 0. Let G1_1, G2_2, ..., Gn_n be nn circles of equal radius r>0r > 0. Suppose each of the nn circles G1_1, G2_2, ..., Gn_n touches the circle G externally. Also, for i=1,2,...,n−1i = 1, 2, ..., n-1, the circle Gi_i touches Gi+1_{i+1} externally, and Gn_n touches G1_1 externally. Then, which of the following statements is/are TRUE?

SOLUTION

Let the centre of the big circle GG be OO and its radius be RR.
Each small circle GiG_i has centre AiA_i and radius rr.

Because every GiG_i touches GG externally, the distance OAiOA_i is the sum of the radii: OAi=R+rOA_i = R + r.
Because consecutive circles GiG_i and Gi+1G_{i+1} touch externally, the distance between their centres is AiAi+1=2rA_iA_{i+1}=2r.

The centres A1,A2,…,AnA_1,A_2,\ldots ,A_n are therefore the vertices of a regular nn-gon inscribed in the circle with centre OO and radius R+rR+r.
Hence the central angle between two consecutive vertices is θ=2πn\theta = \dfrac{2\pi}{n}.

Consider the isosceles triangle OAiAi+1OA_iA_{i+1}. Applying the cosine rule,

AiAi+12=OAi2+OAi+12−2(OAi)(OAi+1)cos⁡θ(2r)2=(R+r)2+(R+r)2−2(R+r)2cos⁡θ4r2=2(R+r)2(1−cos⁡θ).\begin{aligned} A_iA_{i+1}^2 &= OA_i^2 + OA_{i+1}^2 - 2(OA_i)(OA_{i+1})\cos\theta \\ (2r)^2 &= (R+r)^2 + (R+r)^2 - 2(R+r)^2\cos\theta \\ 4r^2 &= 2(R+r)^2\bigl(1-\cos\theta\bigr). \end{aligned}

Rearranging gives

(R+r)2=2r21−cos⁡θ,R+r=2 r1−cos⁡θ,R=r ⁣(21−cos⁡θ−1).−(1)\begin{aligned} (R+r)^2 &= \frac{2r^2}{1-\cos\theta},\\ R+r &= \frac{\sqrt{2}\,r}{\sqrt{1-\cos\theta}},\\ R &= r\!\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{1-\cos\theta}} - 1\right).\qquad -(1) \end{aligned}

Thus the ratio Rr\dfrac{R}{r} depends only on nn through θ=2πn\theta=\dfrac{2\pi}{n}.

Case 1: n=4    (θ=π2,  cos⁡θ=0)n = 4 \;\;(\theta=\dfrac{\pi}{2},\; \cos\theta = 0)

Rr=2−1,so R=(2−1) r.\dfrac{R}{r}= \sqrt{2}-1,\qquad\text{so } R = (\sqrt{2}-1)\,r. Option A claims (2−1)r<R(\sqrt{2}-1)r \lt R, but we have equality; therefore Option A is false.

Case 2: n=5    (θ=2π5,  cos⁡θ≈0.3090)n = 5 \;\;(\theta=\dfrac{2\pi}{5},\; \cos\theta\approx 0.3090)

Rr=21−0.3090−1≈1.41420.8312−1≈0.698.\dfrac{R}{r}= \frac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{1-0.3090}}-1 \approx \frac{1.4142}{0.8312}-1 \approx 0.698. Hence R≈0.698 r,R\approx 0.698\,r, i.e. R<r.R \lt r. Option B states r<Rr \lt R, which is false.

Case 3: n=8    (θ=π4,  cos⁡θ=22=0.7071)n = 8 \;\;(\theta=\dfrac{\pi}{4},\; \cos\theta=\dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{2}=0.7071)

Rr=21−0.7071−1=1.41420.2929−1=1.41420.5412−1≈1.613.\dfrac{R}{r}= \frac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{1-0.7071}}-1 = \frac{1.4142}{\sqrt{0.2929}}-1 = \frac{1.4142}{0.5412}-1 \approx 1.613. Therefore R≈1.613 r>(2−1) r  (≈0.414 r).R \approx 1.613\,r \gt (\sqrt{2}-1)\,r\;(\approx 0.414\,r). So the inequality (2−1)r<R(\sqrt{2}-1)r \lt R holds. Option C is true.

Case 4: n=12    (θ=π6,  cos⁡θ=32=0.8660)n = 12 \;\;(\theta=\dfrac{\pi}{6},\; \cos\theta=\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}=0.8660)

Rr=21−0.8660−1=1.41420.1340−1=1.41420.3660−1≈2.866.\dfrac{R}{r}= \frac{\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{1-0.8660}}-1 = \frac{1.4142}{\sqrt{0.1340}}-1 = \frac{1.4142}{0.3660}-1 \approx 2.866. Compute 2(3+1)=1.4142 (1.732+1)=1.4142×2.732≈3.866.\sqrt{2}(\sqrt{3}+1) = 1.4142\,(1.732 + 1) = 1.4142 \times 2.732 \approx 3.866. Since 3.866 r>2.866 r=R,3.866\,r \gt 2.866\,r = R, we have 2(3+1)r>R.\sqrt{2}(\sqrt{3}+1)r \gt R. Option D is true.

Hence the correct statements are:
Option C (If n=8n = 8, then (2−1)r<R(\sqrt{2}-1)r \lt R)
Option D (If n=12n = 12, then 2(3+1)r>R\sqrt{2}(\sqrt{3}+1)r \gt R).

Tagged Position of two circles and common tangents. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

ChapterCircles
TopicPosition of two circles and common tangents
TypeMultiple correct