RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2023 · PAPER 1+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2023 Mathematics question — Area between curves

Let f:[0,1]→[0,1]f : [0, 1] \to [0, 1] be the function defined by f(x)=x33−x2+59x+1736f(x) = \frac{x^3}{3} - x^2 + \frac{5}{9}x + \frac{17}{36}. Consider the square region S=[0,1]×[0,1]S = [0, 1] \times [0, 1]. Let G={(x,y)∈S:y>f(x)}G = \{(x, y) \in S : y > f(x)\} be called the green region and R={(x,y)∈S:y<f(x)}R = \{(x, y) \in S : y < f(x)\} be called the red region. Let Lh={(x,h)∈S:x∈[0,1]}L_h = \{(x, h) \in S : x \in [0, 1]\} be the horizontal line drawn at a height h∈[0,1]h \in [0, 1]. Then which of the following statements is(are) true?

SOLUTION

Let f:[0,1]→[0,1]f:[0,1]\rightarrow[0,1] be given by f(x)=x33−x2+59x+1736f(x)=\dfrac{x^{3}}{3}-x^{2}+\dfrac{5}{9}x+\dfrac{17}{36} and let the unit square be S=[0,1]×[0,1]S=[0,1]\times[0,1].

Throughout the solution we denote by G above(h)=area of {(x,y)∈S:y>h and y>f(x)}G_{\,\text{above}}(h)=\text{area of }\{(x,y)\in S:y\gt h\text{ and }y\gt f(x)\} G below(h)=area of {(x,y)∈S:y<h and y>f(x)}G_{\,\text{below}}(h)=\text{area of }\{(x,y)\in S:y\lt h\text{ and }y\gt f(x)\} R above(h)=area of {(x,y)∈S:y>h and y<f(x)}R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=\text{area of }\{(x,y)\in S:y\gt h\text{ and }y\lt f(x)\} R below(h)=area of {(x,y)∈S:y<h and y<f(x)}R_{\,\text{below}}(h)=\text{area of }\{(x,y)\in S:y\lt h\text{ and }y\lt f(x)\}

All four quantities depend continuously on h∈[0,1]h\in[0,1], because the integrands that define them are continuous in hh.

Step 1: Total red area and total green area
For every fixed x∈[0,1]x\in[0,1] the red part occupies the vertical segment 0≤y≤f(x)0\le y\le f(x) and the green part the segment f(x)≤y≤1f(x)\le y\le 1. Hence
(total red area)=∫01f(x) dx,(total green area)=1−∫01f(x) dx.\text{(total red area)}=\int_{0}^{1}f(x)\,dx,\qquad \text{(total green area)}=1-\int_{0}^{1}f(x)\,dx. Compute the integral:

∫01f(x) dx=∫01 ⁣(x33−x2+59x+1736) ⁣dx=112−13+518+1736=1836=12.\int_{0}^{1}f(x)\,dx =\int_{0}^{1}\!\left(\frac{x^{3}}{3}-x^{2}+\frac{5}{9}x+\frac{17}{36}\right)\!dx =\frac{1}{12}-\frac{1}{3}+\frac{5}{18}+\frac{17}{36} =\frac{18}{36}=\frac12.

Therefore
Total red area=12,Total green area=12.\boxed{\text{Total red area}= \dfrac12},\qquad \boxed{\text{Total green area}= \dfrac12}.

Step 2: Minimum and maximum values of f(x)f(x)
The derivative is f′(x)=x2−2x+59=(x−13)(x−53).f'(x)=x^{2}-2x+\dfrac59=(x-\tfrac13)(x-\tfrac53). The only critical point in [0,1][0,1] is x=13x=\tfrac13, and because f′′(x)=2x−2f''(x)=2x-2, f′′(13)=−43<0f''(\tfrac13)=-\dfrac43\lt0, that point is a maximum. Consequently the minimum occurs at one of the end-points:

f(0)=1736=0.4722…,f(1)=13−1+59+1736=0.3611….f(0)=\frac{17}{36}=0.4722\ldots,\qquad f(1)=\frac13-1+\frac59+\frac{17}{36}=0.3611\ldots. Hence 0.361<f(x)<0.559   for every x∈[0,1].\boxed{0.361\lt f(x)\lt 0.559\;\text{ for every }x\in[0,1]}. In particular f(x)>14f(x)\gt\dfrac14 and f(x)<23f(x)\lt\dfrac23 for every x∈[0,1]x\in[0,1]. These facts will be used repeatedly.

Step 3: Red-region equality R above(h)=R below(h)R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=R_{\,\text{below}}(h) (Option B)
For each hh R above(h)=∫01max⁡ ⁣(f(x)−h,0) dx,R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=\int_{0}^{1}\max\!\bigl(f(x)-h,0\bigr)\,dx, R below(h)=∫01min⁡ ⁣(f(x),h) dx.R_{\,\text{below}}(h)=\int_{0}^{1}\min\!\bigl(f(x),h\bigr)\,dx. If f(x)≥hf(x)\ge h the first integrand is f(x)−hf(x)-h and the second hh; if f(x)≤hf(x)\le h the first is 00 and the second f(x)f(x). Hence for every xx max⁡(f(x)−h,0)+min⁡(f(x),h)=f(x)\max(f(x)-h,0)+\min(f(x),h)=f(x) which gives R above(h)+R below(h)=∫01f(x) dx=12.R_{\,\text{above}}(h)+R_{\,\text{below}}(h)=\int_{0}^{1}f(x)\,dx=\frac12. We therefore need R above(h)=14.R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=\dfrac14. Define ϕ(h)=R above(h).\phi(h)=R_{\,\text{above}}(h). Because ϕ(0)=12\phi(0)=\tfrac12 and ϕ(1)=0\phi(1)=0, by the Intermediate Value Theorem there exists some hh with ϕ(h)=14\phi(h)=\tfrac14. The choice h=14h=\dfrac14 itself works, because f(x)>14f(x)\gt\dfrac14 for every xx, so R above ⁣(14)=∫01 ⁣(f(x)−14) dx=12−14=14.R_{\,\text{above}}\!\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\int_{0}^{1}\!(f(x)-\tfrac14)\,dx =\frac12-\frac14=\frac14. Thus a suitable hh lies in [14,23]\bigl[\tfrac14,\tfrac23\bigr], proving Option B is true.

Step 4: Green-above equals Red-below G above(h)=R below(h)G_{\,\text{above}}(h)=R_{\,\text{below}}(h) (Option C)
Write Φ(h)=G above(h)−R below(h).\Phi(h)=G_{\,\text{above}}(h)-R_{\,\text{below}}(h). Using the facts G above(h)+R above(h)=1−h,G below(h)+R below(h)=h,G_{\,\text{above}}(h)+R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=1-h,\qquad G_{\,\text{below}}(h)+R_{\,\text{below}}(h)=h, we still evaluate directly at the two end-points of the interval in the option:

• For h=14h=\dfrac14, since f(x)>14f(x)\gt\dfrac14 for all xx, G above ⁣(14)=∫01(1−f(x)) dx=12,G_{\,\text{above}}\!\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\int_{0}^{1}(1-f(x))\,dx=\frac12, R below ⁣(14)=∫0114 dx=14,R_{\,\text{below}}\!\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\int_{0}^{1}\tfrac14\,dx=\tfrac14, so Φ ⁣(14)=12−14=14>0.\Phi\!\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\tfrac12-\tfrac14=\tfrac14\gt0.

• For h=23h=\dfrac23, because f(x)<23f(x)\lt\dfrac23 for every xx, G above ⁣(23)=∫01(1−23) dx=13,G_{\,\text{above}}\!\bigl(\tfrac23\bigr)=\int_{0}^{1}(1-\tfrac23)\,dx=\tfrac13, R below ⁣(23)=∫01f(x) dx=12,R_{\,\text{below}}\!\bigl(\tfrac23\bigr)=\int_{0}^{1}f(x)\,dx=\tfrac12, so Φ ⁣(23)=13−12=−16<0.\Phi\!\bigl(\tfrac23\bigr)=\tfrac13-\tfrac12=-\tfrac16\lt0.

Because Φ(h)\Phi(h) is continuous and changes sign between h=14h=\tfrac14 and h=23h=\tfrac23, there exists some h∈(14,23)h\in\bigl(\tfrac14,\tfrac23\bigr) with Φ(h)=0,\Phi(h)=0, establishing Option C as true.

Step 5: Red-above equals Green-below R above(h)=G below(h)R_{\,\text{above}}(h)=G_{\,\text{below}}(h) (Option D)
Put Ψ(h)=R above(h)−G below(h).\Psi(h)=R_{\,\text{above}}(h)-G_{\,\text{below}}(h). A direct calculation shows Φ(h)+Ψ(h)=(1−h)−h=1−2h.\Phi(h)+\Psi(h)=(1-h)-h=1-2h. We already know Φ(h)\Phi(h) is continuous; hence so is Ψ(h)\Psi(h). Again evaluate at the two ends:

• h=14:R above=14,  G below=0  ⟹  Ψ(14)=14>0.h=\dfrac14:\qquad R_{\,\text{above}}=\tfrac14,\; G_{\,\text{below}}=0\;\Longrightarrow\; \Psi\bigl(\tfrac14\bigr)=\tfrac14\gt0.

• h=23:R above=0,  G below=16  ⟹  Ψ(23)=−16<0.h=\dfrac23:\qquad R_{\,\text{above}}=0,\; G_{\,\text{below}}=\tfrac16\;\Longrightarrow\; \Psi\bigl(\tfrac23\bigr)=-\tfrac16\lt0.

Since Ψ(h)\Psi(h) changes sign on [14,23]\bigl[\tfrac14,\tfrac23\bigr], an hh in this interval satisfies Ψ(h)=0\Psi(h)=0, proving Option D is true.

Step 6: Green-above equals Green-below (Option A)
For the green region we want G above(h)=G below(h).G_{\,\text{above}}(h)=G_{\,\text{below}}(h). Because the total green area is 12\tfrac12, the equality is equivalent to G above(h)=14.G_{\,\text{above}}(h)=\tfrac14. Define γ(h)=G above(h).\gamma(h)=G_{\,\text{above}}(h). We have already obtained γ(0)=12,γ ⁣(23)=13.\gamma(0)=\tfrac12,\qquad \gamma\!\bigl(\tfrac23\bigr)=\tfrac13. Thus on [0,23][0,\tfrac23] the value of γ(h)\gamma(h) stays at least 13>14,\tfrac13\gt\tfrac14, so it can equal 14\tfrac14 only for some h>23h\gt\tfrac23. Consequently no hh in [14,23]\bigl[\tfrac14,\tfrac23\bigr] satisfies the required condition, and Option A is false.

Conclusion
The correct statements are:
Option B, Option C and Option D.

Hence the answer is:
Option B (red above = red below), Option C (green above = red below) and Option D (red above = green below).

Tagged Area between curves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicArea between curves
TypeMultiple correct