To check the principle of multiple proportions, a series of pure binary compounds (PQ) were analyzed and their composition is tabulated below. The correct option(s) is(are)
| Compound | Weight % of P | Weight % of Q |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 50 | 50 |
| 2 | 44.4 | 55.6 |
| 3 | 40 | 60 |
First extract the data from the table given in the question.
Compound 1 mass ratio
Compound 2 mass ratio
Compound 3 mass ratio
Case 1: Checking Option A - “If empirical formula of compound 3 is , then empirical formula of compound 2 is .”
For compound 3 assume .
Weight ratio
With the same atomic masses, the ratio for (suggested for compound 2) would be
The experimental ratio for compound 2 is , not .
Hence Option A is WRONG.
Case 2: Checking Option B - “If empirical formula of compound 3 is and atomic weight of P is 20, atomic weight of Q is 45.”
Assume and empirical formula for compound 3.
Mass of P in one empirical unit =
Let . Mass of Q in one empirical unit = .
Percentage of P: (from data of compound 3)
Thus .
Option B is CORRECT.
Case 3: Checking Option C - “If empirical formula of compound 2 is , then empirical formula of compound 1 is .”
For compound 2 let empirical formula be .
Weight ratio take .
With these atomic masses, the ratio for (suggested for compound 1) becomes
This matches the experimental ratio of compound 1 (50 % : 50 % 1 : 1).
Hence Option C is CORRECT.
Case 4: Checking Option D - “If atomic weights of P and Q are 70 and 35 respectively, empirical formula of compound 1 is .”
Given , compound 1 has equal masses of P and Q.
To get equal masses: number of moles .
Thus the simplest integer formula is , not .
Option D is WRONG.
Therefore the correct choices are:
Option B (atomic weight of Q is 45) and Option C (empirical formula ).
Final answer: Option B, Option C.
Tagged Units, significant figures and laws of chemical combination. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.