JEE Advanced 2023 Chemistry question — Crystal lattices, unit cells and density
Atoms of metals x, y, and z form face-centred cubic (fcc) unit cell of edge length Lx, body-centred cubic (bcc) unit cell of edge length Ly, and simple cubic unit cell of edge length Lz, respectively.
If rz=23ry; ry=38rx; Mz=23My and Mz=3Mx, then the correct statement(s) is (are)
[Given: Mx, My, and Mz are molar masses of metals x, y, and z, respectively. rx, ry, and rz are atomic radii of metals x, y, and z, respectively.]
SOLUTION
For every cubic lattice the density, edge length and packing efficiency depend on three basic data: number of atoms per unit cell (Z), atomic radius (r) and molar mass (M). We tabulate the standard relations first:
Face-centred cubic (fcc, metal x):
• Zx=4 • contact along a face diagonal ⇒2Lx=4rx⇒rx=22Lx.
Body-centred cubic (bcc, metal y):
• Zy=2 • contact along a body diagonal ⇒3Ly=4ry⇒ry=43Ly.
Simple cubic (sc, metal z):
• Zz=1 • contact along an edge ⇒Lz=2rz⇒rz=2Lz.
The question gives the inter-relations
rz=23ry,ry=38rx,Mz=23My,Mz=3Mx.
From the last two equalities
Mx=31Mz,My=32Mz⟹MyMx=21.
1. Comparison of edge lengths
Using ry=38rx in Ly=34ry: Ly=34(38rx)=332rx.
Using rz=23ry=23(38rx)=4rx in Lz=2rz: Lz=8rx.
For fcc, Lx=22rx.
Numerically (in units of rx): Lx=2.828rx,Ly=10.667rx,Lz=8rx.
Therefore Ly>Lz>Lx and hence Option B (Ly>Lz) is correct, while Option C (Lx>Ly) is incorrect.
2. Packing efficiencies
Standard values are: fcc = 74 %, bcc = 68 %, sc = 52.4 %.
Thusfcc (x)>bcc (y)>sc (z),so Option A is correct.
3. Density comparison of x and y
For any cubic lattice ρ=NAL3ZM. Taking the ratio
ρyρx=ZyMyLx3ZxMxLy3=(24)(MyMx)(LxLy)3=2(21)(LxLy)3=(LxLy)3.
We already have LxLy=2232/3=3216≈3.772,
so
ρyρx≈3.7723≈53.7>1.
Hence ρx>ρy, making Option D correct.
Final verdict: Correct statements: Option A, Option B, Option D.
Tagged Crystal lattices, unit cells and density. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.