A colorless aqueous solution contains nitrates of two metals, X and Y. When it was added to an aqueous solution of NaCl, a white precipitate was formed. This precipitate was found to be partly soluble in hot water to give a residue P and a solution Q. The residue P was soluble in aq. and also in excess sodium thiosulfate. The hot solution Q gave a yellow precipitate with KI. The metals X and Y, respectively, are
The original colourless solution contains the nitrates and .
Step 1 - Action of
Adding aqueous produces a white precipitate. White chlorides that precipitate from water are mainly , and . Hence the cations X and Y must come from this group.
Step 2 - Heating the chloride precipitate
The precipitate is “partly soluble” in hot water, giving:
• Residue (insoluble portion)
• Solution (hot filtrate)
Solubility behaviour of the suspected chlorides in hot water:
• - practically insoluble, even on heating.
• - markedly more soluble on heating, dissolves to give in the filtrate.
• - does not dissolve but disproportionates; this is not mentioned.
Therefore, the chloride that remains as residue is and the chloride that enters the hot solution is .
Step 3 - Confirming residue
Residue is stated to dissolve in aqueous as well as in excess . These are the classic confirmatory tests for :
Thus residue and X = Ag.
Step 4 - Confirming solution
The hot solution (which contains the ions that dissolved) gives a yellow precipitate with :
This is the confirmatory test for , so Y = Pb.
Conclusion
X is and Y is .
Option A which is: Ag and Pb
Tagged Group analysis and confirmatory tests of cations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.