Key idea: Hückel's rule: a cyclic, planar, fully conjugated system with (4n+2)π electrons is aromatic.
- P: 3-chlorocyclopropene + AlClX3 loses ClX− to give the cyclopropenyl cation, 2π e (n=0). Aromatic.
- Q: cyclopentadiene + NaH loses HX+ to give the cyclopentadienyl anion, 6π e. Aromatic.
- R: hexane-2,5-dione + (NHX4)X2COX3 (a source of NHX3), heated, undergoes Paal–Knorr synthesis to give 2,5-dimethylpyrrole, 6π e (including the N lone pair). Aromatic.
- S: tropone + HCl protonates the C=O to give the hydroxytropylium cation, 6π e over 7 carbons. Aromatic.
Answer: (A), (B), (C), (D)