RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2010 · PAPER 1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2010 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism

In the Newman projection for 2-2 dimethylbutane

Figure for JEE Advanced 2010 Chemistry question on Structural isomerism

X and Y can respectively be

SOLUTION

Key idea: The Newman projection is staggered. One carbon shows {X,H,H}\{X, \ce{H}, \ce{H}\}, and the other carbon shows {CHX3,CHX3,Y}\{\ce{CH3}, \ce{CH3}, Y\}. Look for a C–C bond in 2,2-dimethylbutane, CHX3−C(CHX3)X2−CHX2−CHX3\ce{CH3-C(CH3)2-CH2-CH3}, whose two carbons carry those substituent sets.

  1. View along C2–C3. C3 carries H, H and CHX3\ce{CH3} (C4), so X=CHX3X = \ce{CH3}. C2 carries three CHX3\ce{CH3} groups, so Y=CHX3Y = \ce{CH3}. This is option (D).
  2. View along C1–C2. C1 carries H, H and H, so X=HX = \ce{H}. C2 carries CHX3\ce{CH3}, CHX3\ce{CH3} and CX2HX5\ce{C2H5}, so Y=CX2HX5Y = \ce{C2H5}. This is option (B).
  3. (A) H and H would need C2 to carry two methyls and one H, but C2 is quaternary.
  4. (C) X=CX2HX5X = \ce{C2H5} with two H's would need a CHX2\ce{CH2} next to an ethyl group, alongside a carbon bearing CHX3,CHX3,H\ce{CH3}, \ce{CH3}, \ce{H}. No bond in the molecule has that pattern.

Answer: (B), (D)

Tagged Structural isomerism. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism
TypeMultiple correct