RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2009 · PAPER 2EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2009 Chemistry question — Reactive intermediates and rearrangements

In the following carbocation, H/CH3H/CH_3 that is most likely to migrate to the positively charged carbon is

Figure for JEE Advanced 2009 Chemistry question on Reactive intermediates and rearrangements
SOLUTION

Key idea: A 1,2-shift happens when it gives a more stable cation. Migration of H from a carbon bearing –OH gives an oxocarbenium ion stabilised by the O lone pair, i.e. a protonated ketone.

The carbocation is CHX3−CH(OH)−CX+H−CH(CHX3)−CHX3\ce{CH3-CH(OH)-C+H-CH(CH3)-CH3} (positive charge at C-3, secondary).

  1. H from C-4 shift: gives (CHX3)X2CX+\ce{(CH3)2C+}–, a tertiary cation. Better, but stabilised only by hyperconjugation and +I.
  2. CH₃ from C-4 shift: gives a secondary cation. No gain.
  3. H from C-2 shift: gives CHX3−CX+(OH)−CHX2X−\ce{CH3-C+(OH)-CH2-}, which has the resonance form CHX3−C(=OX+H)X−\ce{CH3-C(=O+H)-}. Every atom has a complete octet, so this ion is far more stable than any alkyl carbocation. It loses H⁺ to give pentan-2-one (pinacol-like).
  4. CH₃ at C-2: C-2 bears H and OH, not CH₃.

Answer: (D) H at C-2

Tagged Reactive intermediates and rearrangements. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicReactive intermediates and rearrangements
TypeMultiple choice