RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2023 · PAPER 1+3 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2023 Chemistry question — Solubility product and common ion effect

On decreasing the pH from 7 to 2, the solubility of a sparingly soluble salt (MX) of a weak acid (HX) increased from 10−410^{-4} mol L−1^{-1} to 10−310^{-3} mol L−1^{-1}. The pKa_a of HX is:

SOLUTION

Let the sparingly soluble salt be MXMX and its anion be the conjugate base of the weak acid HXHX.

Dissolution equilibrium of the salt: MX(s)⇌M++X−MX(s) \rightleftharpoons M^{+} + X^{-}
Solubility in the given medium = SS mol L−1^{-1} ⇒\Rightarrow [M+]=S[M^{+}] = S.

The anion X−X^{-} is protonated by the hydronium ions present in solution:
X−+H+⇌HXX^{-} + H^{+} \rightleftharpoons HX with Ka=[H+][X−][HX]K_{a} = \dfrac{[H^{+}][X^{-}]}{[HX]}.

Out of the total SS moles of X−X^{-} produced, only a fraction remains as X−X^{-}; let that fraction be α\alpha. Then
[X−]=αS,[HX]=(1−α)S[X^{-}] = \alpha S,\qquad [HX] = (1-\alpha)S.

Applying the definition of KaK_{a}:
Ka=[H+] αS(1−α)S=[H+] α1−α  −(1)K_{a}= \dfrac{[H^{+}]\,\alpha S}{(1-\alpha)S}= [H^{+}]\,\dfrac{\alpha}{1-\alpha} \; -(1)
⇒\Rightarrow α1−α=Ka[H+]  −(2)\dfrac{\alpha}{1-\alpha}= \dfrac{K_{a}}{[H^{+}]} \; -(2)
⇒\Rightarrow α=KaKa+[H+]  −(3)\alpha = \dfrac{K_{a}}{K_{a} + [H^{+}]} \; -(3).

Solubility‐product of the salt:
Ksp=[M+][X−]=S×(αS)=S2 KaKa+[H+]  −(4)K_{sp} = [M^{+}][X^{-}] = S \times (\alpha S)= S^{2}\,\dfrac{K_{a}}{K_{a} + [H^{+}]} \; -(4).

The same KspK_{sp} must hold at every pH. So for two different pH values,

Case 1: pH 7 ⇒\Rightarrow [H+]1=10−7[H^{+}]_{1}=10^{-7} mol L−1^{-1}, given S1=10−4S_{1}=10^{-4} mol L−1^{-1}.
Ksp=S12 KaKa+10−7  −(5)K_{sp}= S_{1}^{2}\,\dfrac{K_{a}}{K_{a}+10^{-7}} \; -(5).

Case 2: pH 2 ⇒\Rightarrow [H+]2=10−2[H^{+}]_{2}=10^{-2} mol L−1^{-1}, given S2=10−3S_{2}=10^{-3} mol L−1^{-1}.
Ksp=S22 KaKa+10−2  −(6)K_{sp}= S_{2}^{2}\,\dfrac{K_{a}}{K_{a}+10^{-2}} \; -(6).

Equate (5)(5) and (6)(6) because KspK_{sp} is constant:

S12Ka+10−7=S22Ka+10−2\dfrac{S_{1}^{2}}{K_{a}+10^{-7}} = \dfrac{S_{2}^{2}}{K_{a}+10^{-2}}

Insert the numerical solubilities:

(10−4)2Ka+10−7=(10−3)2Ka+10−2\dfrac{(10^{-4})^{2}}{K_{a}+10^{-7}} = \dfrac{(10^{-3})^{2}}{K_{a}+10^{-2}}

Simplify the solubility ratio:
(10−4)2=10−8,(10−3)2=10−6(10^{-4})^{2} = 10^{-8}, \quad (10^{-3})^{2} = 10^{-6}
10−8Ka+10−7=10−6Ka+10−2\dfrac{10^{-8}}{K_{a}+10^{-7}} = \dfrac{10^{-6}}{K_{a}+10^{-2}}

Cross-multiply:

10−8(Ka+10−2)=10−6(Ka+10−7)10^{-8}(K_{a}+10^{-2}) = 10^{-6}(K_{a}+10^{-7})

Divide both sides by 10−810^{-8} to clear the powers of 10:

(Ka+10−2)=100 (Ka+10−7)(K_{a}+10^{-2}) = 100\,(K_{a}+10^{-7})

Expand the right side:

Ka+10−2=100Ka+10−5K_{a}+10^{-2} = 100K_{a} + 10^{-5}

Collect like terms:

10−2−10−5=100Ka−Ka=99Ka10^{-2} - 10^{-5} = 100K_{a} - K_{a} = 99K_{a}

Evaluate the left side:
10−2−10−5=0.01−0.00001=0.00999=9.99×10−310^{-2} - 10^{-5} = 0.01 - 0.00001 = 0.00999 = 9.99\times10^{-3}

Hence
Ka=9.99×10−399≈1.0×10−4K_{a} = \dfrac{9.99\times10^{-3}}{99} \approx 1.0\times10^{-4}

Therefore
pKa=−log⁡10(Ka)≈−log⁡10(1.0×10−4)=4pK_{a} = -\log_{10}(K_{a}) \approx -\log_{10}(1.0\times10^{-4}) = 4

So, the pKa_a of the weak acid HXHX is 4.

Option B which is: 4

Tagged Solubility product and common ion effect. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicSolubility product and common ion effect
TypeMultiple choice