RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2024 · PAPER 1+3 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2024 Chemistry question — Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes

Among the following options, select the option in which each complex in Set-I shows geometrical isomerism and the two complexes in Set-II are ionization isomers of each other.

[en = H2NCH2CH2NH2H_2NCH_2CH_2NH_2]

SOLUTION

For this problem we have to verify, for every option (A-D), two separate conditions.
1. Both complexes listed in Set-I must be able to exist as geometrical (cis-trans, fac-mer etc.) isomers.
2. The two complexes listed in Set-II must be ionization isomers of each other (i.e. they must have the same overall formula, but an interchange of an ion inside the coordination sphere with the counter-ion outside).

Condition for geometrical isomerism
• Tetrahedral complexes never show geometrical isomerism.
• Square-planar complexes of the type MA2B2,  MA2BCMA_2B_2,\; MA_2BC etc. show cis-trans isomerism.
• Octahedral complexes show geometrical isomerism when at least two different kinds of ligands are present in suitable numbers, e.g. MA4B2MA_4B_2 (cis/trans) and MA3B3MA_3B_3 (fac/mer).
• Octahedral MA5BMA_5B possesses only one possible arrangement, hence no geometrical isomerism.

Condition for ionization isomerism
Two complexes are ionization isomers when the total empirical formula (including counter-ions) is the same and an anionic ligand inside the coordination sphere interchanges with an anion that was outside it.

Now we analyse each option.

Option A

Set-I : [Ni(CO)4][Ni(CO)_4] is tetrahedral ⇒\Rightarrow no geometrical isomerism. Hence Condition 1 already fails. Option A is rejected.

Option B

Set-I :
• [Co(en)(NH3)2Cl2][Co(en)(NH_3)_2Cl_2] is octahedral of the type M(A ⁣− ⁣A)B2C2M(A\!-\!A)B_2C_2 (here en is bidentate), so cis-trans is possible.
• [PdCl2(PPh3)2][PdCl_2(PPh_3)_2] is square-planar MA2B2MA_2B_2, again cis-trans possible. Thus Condition 1 is satisfied.
Set-II : [Co(NH3)6][Cr(CN)6][Co(NH_3)_6][Cr(CN)_6] and [Cr(NH3)6][Co(CN)6][Cr(NH_3)_6][Co(CN)_6] have completely different ions inside the coordination spheres (the metals themselves are interchanged). They are not obtained by simply exchanging a counter-ion with a ligand. Therefore they are not ionization isomers. Option B is rejected.

Option C

Set-I :
• [Co(NH3)3(NO2)3][Co(NH_3)_3(NO_2)_3] is octahedral MA3B3MA_3B_3 and exists as fac (facial) and mer (meridional) isomers →\rightarrow geometrical isomerism present.
• [Co(en)2Cl2][Co(en)_2Cl_2] is octahedral M(A ⁣− ⁣A)2B2M(A\!-\!A)_2B_2; the two Cl−Cl^- ligands can be cis (adjacent) or trans (opposite) →\rightarrow geometrical isomerism present. Condition 1 is fulfilled.
Set-II : [Co(NH3)5Cl]SO4[Co(NH_3)_5Cl]SO_4 and [Co(NH3)5(SO4)]Cl[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]Cl have identical overall formula [Co(NH3)5Cl]SO4[Co(NH_3)_5Cl]SO_4. One complex contains Cl−Cl^- inside and SO42−SO_4^{2-} outside; the other has SO42−SO_4^{2-} inside and Cl−Cl^- outside. They are classic ionization isomers. Condition 2 is also fulfilled.

Option D

Set-I : [Cr(NH3)5Cl]2+[Cr(NH_3)_5Cl]^{2+} is octahedral MA5BMA_5B; all five NH3 positions are equivalent and there is only one possible arrangement. Hence no geometrical isomerism. Condition 1 fails →\rightarrow Option D is rejected (further, its Set-II involves hydrate rather than ionization isomerism).

Only Option C satisfies both required conditions.

Option C which is: Set-I [Co(NH3)3(NO2)3][Co(NH_3)_3(NO_2)_3] and [Co(en)2Cl2][Co(en)_2Cl_2]; Set-II [Co(NH3)5Cl]SO4[Co(NH_3)_5Cl]SO_4 and [Co(NH3)5(SO4)]Cl[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]Cl

Tagged Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeometrical and optical isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice